Everyone Thinks They're the Exception
This bias is pervasive in boardrooms and pitch meetings, quietly undermining companies.
The Overconfidence Trap:
One of the most robust findings in behavioral science is the "above-average effect"—the tendency for individuals to rate their own skills and prospects higher than those of their peers.
It shows up everywhere: in one classic survey, up to 93% of drivers claimed to be better than average behind the wheel. The math makes that impossible.
Confidence is essential in startups and investing. Founders need it to launch, and investors need it to place bold bets. However, when confidence shifts into overconfidence, the costs are tangible: inaccurate forecasts, mispriced risk, and preventable failures.
Founders: Certainty vs. Reality
A survey of 2,994 entrepreneurs revealed a stark gap between belief and reality:
81% believed their chance of success was at least 70%.
One-third claimed a 100% chance, absolute certainty.
The historical base rate? Only 25% of new businesses survive past their fifth year. That means three out of four will close their doors, regardless of the founders' confidence.
This isn't just optimism. It's overplacement. The conviction that "my startup will beat the odds." It drives premature scaling, aggressive hiring, and a habit of dismissing warning signs because "those failures aren't like us."
Venture Capitalists: Confidence Without Accuracy
Venture capitalists pride themselves on pattern recognition and gut feel. But experience can harden into confirmation bias, the sense that you've seen this movie before and already know the ending.
In a seminal study, 96% of VCs exhibited significant overconfidence in decision-making. Paradoxically, those most certain about their picks were the least accurate.
Most VC fund managers expect top-quartile returns, even though only 25% of funds can achieve them. This misplaced confidence is evident in portfolio math, where actual returns often fall short of expectations. More data doesn't always help but frequently increases confidence without improving accuracy.
Angel Investors: The Overconfidence Trap
Angel investors are no exception. A Harvard-reported study found that 91% of angels succumbed to overconfidence at least once, making it the most common and damaging bias affecting their returns.
Angels often rely on gut feel and first impressions. When a charismatic founder presents a compelling narrative, it's easy to downplay contradictory signals. Nearly every angel believes they can out-pick the market or algorithms. Statistically, that can't be true.
Why It Matters
Overconfidence isn't just a harmless quirk; it can be a significant hindrance to effective decision-making. It encourages excessive risk-taking and delays course corrections:
Founders burn cash chasing markets that never materialize.
VCs double down on deals that should have been written off.
Angels over-concentrate in a few "sure things," amplifying losses.
The result? Too many Founders and Investors wait too long to face reality.
Counter-Moves That Work
Research offers proven ways to recalibrate confidence:
Premortems: Before launching or funding, imagine the venture has already failed. Ask: What killed it?
External dissent: Invite outsiders (board members, advisors, or algorithms) to critique assumptions.
Evidence-based forecasting: Base projections on industry data, not best-case scenarios.
Confidence is essential, but it must coexist with humility. If you're sure you'll beat the odds, you're already in the danger zone.
A Reality Check for Every Stakeholder
Founders: Would you still start this company if you believed you had only a 1-in-4 chance of surviving five years?
VCs and Angels: Would you still write this check if you assumed your predictive accuracy was no better than a coin flip?
Answering "yes" after confronting those numbers shows healthy confidence. Anything else is likely biased talk.
Your Turn
Have you seen overconfidence sink a deal, a startup, or a fund? What helped, or came too late? Share your experience. The more we discuss this bias, the more difficult it becomes to remain hidden.
Ready to see your company’s recovery score? Visit www.recoveryoddsindex.com